Works 1965-1995
$96.99
Performances (and music) lack passion and beauty - Steve Reich, unlike most classical composers, is well-known in the popular music world owing to his influence on many musicians of the post rock period.After having heard and been impressed by his Six Pianos and Four Organs, I was eager to hear a full collection of his material since he began composing in the 1960s. However, there is really little of note in the ten discs of Steve Reich 1965-1995.Even the two pieces whose first two performances I initially liked are not performed as well here - and with hindsight they are nothing compared to, say, Messiaen s organ works in terms of emotion and depth. The rest of the work here is no better, for instance the acclamied Music for 18 Musicians certainly lacks the passion of the post-rock it is often claimed to have been a major influence on. It also is very boring because the many instruments are unable to show the subtle variations of texture that are often possible with a single instrument, especially one liek an organ. Some of Reich s works, even if prelude to the sampling era, are just annoying noise created by tape loops that seem out of place in a work devoted to classical music.His later work, though easier to listen to, approaches blandness and the orchestras seem to be playing something that has been played before.It s really good to be able to notice the mediocre music in the classical, as well as the popular field, and this is amongst them. you will not gain much by hearing this lengthy set. There is much better music amongst modern classical composers.
Classic, but not the definitive... - While a multi CD collection spanning 30 years does sound very promsing, Nonesuch cannot offer all of the best recordings of some of Reich s masterpieces (Music for 18 Musicians or Drumming), and some have been missed out completely (Music for a Large Ensemble), presumably because the piece was not recorded under the Nonesuch label. While the collection is formidable, a listener wanting to hear the best recordings of all the pieces might do better seeking out the older (or longer!) recordings of the pieces.
Essential - The term essential gets thrown about too much. And heck, the claim that certain words get thrown about too much gets thrown about too much. But here is a collection that really *is* essential to understanding the nature of a whole shift not just in classical music, but in popular music and indeed in popular culture. So many of Reich s ideas and concepts have become so deeply embedded in current classical music, film scoring (any number of examples, but think about Tangerine Dream s score for Risky Business and Hans Zimmer s score for Thin Red Line, for starters), electronic music and even the visual arts.This box set gives the listener all of Reich s major works. I can t even attempt to describe them individually, but every one of these 10 CDs is compelling. For the totally uninitiated, take out Music for 18 Musicians (presented here in a crystalline new recording) to get an idea of what the core of this guy is all about. From there, you might want to listen to Different Trains, Electric Counterpoint and Six Marimbas to get an idea of the pointillistic pulse minimalism that Reich contributed to the world. The earlier material is the more challenging, exploring the subtleties of rythym, phase relationships between sounds and shifting timings. Among these, the new recording of Four Organs is just outstanding.Reich s works, along with the early works of Terry Riley and Philip Glass, form the foundation of an enormous edifice that has grown of music that attempts to return to its essential and hypnotic roots. With this box set, one of those pylons becomes clear.